Dakarai Turner

The Battle of the Stories: Snapchat vs Instagram

September 6, 2016
Instagram Stories

Instagram Story

It’s been a little over a month since the introduction of the Snapchat copy/paste, Instagram Stories, and I think it’s fair to say that the platform hasn’t necessarily “blown” up yet. The social network carries an impressive 500 million monthly active users (as we spoke about in a June weekly recap), but converting people to ditch Snapchat is going to take a lot longer than they may have anticipated. I mean, we can’t all have the growth of Pokémon Go at the end of the day. Last week, the number’s revealed results that weren’t exactly too shocking if you’ve been observing your Instagram feed the last month.

“About a month into the launch of Instagram’s Stories feature, we are still not seeing a significant increase of time spent in the app versus Snapchat,” said by Danielle Levitas, the SVP of a research group in the U.S. that conducted a study on both platforms. Maybe it’s just me, but I follow almost 700 people on Instagram, and on any given day I don’t see any more than 15 Stories, which is mostly by public figures and brands. The majority of my friends just simply aren’t using it. One thing I did notice is that whenever I would post an Instagram Story, the amount of views I would receive would almost triple my Snapchat views. This is likely the case with most people. You have more followers on Instagram than friends on Snapchat. With that being said, this is the reason why we love Snapchat so much.

Snapchat is Personal

Instagram is your personal brand, while Snapchat is your personal life. By this I mean that we generally post things on Instagram that show us at our best, whether that’s some sort of accomplishment or simply the best possible picture of you at an event. Your Instagram feed is for capturing memories (in my opinion). Now Snapchat on the other hand, is for capturing moments. These are things that you want to share with people right now, and that won’t necessarily matter tomorrow. To some of you this may be incredibly obvious, but this is the reason why I don’t think Instagram Stories will be able to replace Snapchat. The two apps serve different purposes.

Although the reach potential is higher on Instagram, you don’t really post Stories to see how many people are going to view them, unless you’re promoting something or trying to create awareness. For brands, Instagram Stories works well because of the sheer size of the audience. For regular people posting funny selfies and embarrassing videos of their friends, Instagram probably isn’t the best platform.

With that being said, there are a lot of improvements Instagram needs to make in order to have people flocking towards it. For starters, distancing themselves from Snapchat would be great. As of right now it appears as the lesser exciting twin of Snapchat, and in order to grow, they’ll need to establish themselves as a separate entity. There needs to be clear features on Instagram Stories that can’t be done on Snapchat. Obviously this is easier said than done.

Instagram Stories

The fact is, it’s only been a month. I personally think that there will be plenty of interesting updates to come to Instagram Stories throughout the rest of the year. And as always, we’ll be talking about them here! For now, you can follow me on Instagram and look out for my amazing stories. Also, I’d love to know your thoughts on both platforms, so drop us a comment below!


Dakarai is an ambitious professional with a passion for advertising and marketing, and is currently employed as an account coordinator for an ad agency in Toronto. When he’s not at the office, he’s most likely trying out a new restaurant, browsing AdWeek, or binge watching something on Netflix. Dakarai, but you can call him Dak. Follow him on TwitterInstagram, and connect with him on LinkedIn.

You Might Also Like

No Comments

Let us know what you think!